Archive for November, 2007

Fifth Visit

November 30, 2007

I had my fifth and next-to-last visit with Sharon today. I didn’t have anything planned (which has been a consistent fault on my part), and Sharon wanted to know if there’s anything that would be useful to her that we hadn’t gone over yet. Fortunately, wikis came to mind, which is what we spent the remainder of our time working through. It was kind of tough to start with, though, because I had to try and explain the concept behind wikis. I’ve never been the best at verbalizing things (though I’m apparently a pretty good writer), so it took me several attempts to get my idea formulated. It was also difficult because I’m not very familiar with wikis to start with and my conceptualization of how they’re different from blogs is still fuzzy.

Even after I explained it, Sharon still had a tough time getting her head around why anyone would want to use a wiki (or blog, for that matter). She looked askance at such communications because she felt that many of them were rambling (like my own); poorly written;  pointless; and self-centered, all of which characterize many, many blogs on the Web, and probably many wikis, too. I think she was too focused on the negatives, though, for a well-constructed blog or wiki can be a very powerful tool. By the end of our time together, I think she had a pretty good understanding of the benefits of wikis and blogs and when each is most appropriate to use.

My visit also brought up two themes that have run through all our sessions–conceptualization and patience. First, conceptualization is very important to Sharon, as would be expected with a teacher. I’m often poor at explaining concepts, though, which is a problem. Analogies and common understandings are key to that explaining, but I can’t think of any teaching analogies because I have no experience with them and I feel that Sharon and I really don’t have similar enough backgrounds to get common understanding.

I’ve often been surprised at Sharon’s lack of patience. She’s the type of person that wants the gist of things right away and then moves on to the next thing. I understand where she’s coming from, as I’m the same way, but I don’t think my impatience is as pronounced as hers. Were our roles reversed, though, I might well act similarly. In any event, this impatience makes my teaching more difficult because my poor explanatory skills and her limited knowledge means it takes longer for us to come to an understanding and ends up becoming a frustrating experience. With regards to wikis, I’m not sure if Sharon has the patience to learn the (admittedly limited) syntax required on most wikis for formatting purposes. We’ll see next week, when I show her how to use pbwiki (http://pbwiki.com/).

Reflections Paper

November 28, 2007

I know this was supposed to be an outline of my paper, but to be honest, I haven’t gotten anything together for it. This is partly because I have no idea what I’m going to do with the paper and it’s kind of got me panicky because I’m overwhelmed by it and everything else I have to do before the semester ends. I also feel like I don’t have anywhere near enough service-learning time to draw on due to logistical conflicts, and I don’t know how much of the wikipedia articles I’m going to be able to edit. 

For what it’s worth, these are some of my random thoughts:

  • disconnect between readings & service learning (learning very basic, readings very theoretical/cerebral
  • what are the long-term fruits of my service learning (will the teaching trickle down to the kids)?
  • what I learned in service learning
    • patience
    • tough to know what people know & what they don’t
    • people are really good with some programs but not others
    • organization is key for inexperienced users so they don’t get overwhelmed
  • unsatisfying service learning experience
    • i was first to set up my experience, but perhaps got least out of it

 Here are some articles & books I think I might use:

“Service-Learning as Postmodern Pedagogy” by Dan Butin in Service-Learning in Higher Education, ed. by Dan Butin

The Academic Citizen by Bruce Macfarlane

Learning to Serve: Promoting Civil Society Through Service Learning

Perspectives of Five Library and Information Studies Students Involved in Service Learning at a… in Journal of Education for Library & Information Science | 2001-0442:2, | 86(10)

Where’s the Library in Service Learning?: Models for Engaged Library Instruction.
Riddle, John S. | Journal of Academic Librarianship | 2003-0329:2

Service-Learning and LIS Education.
Yontz, Elaine; McCook, Kathleen de la Peña | Journal of Education for Library & Information Science | 2003-0144:1, | 58(11)

Pre-Turkey Thoughts

November 20, 2007

I was supposed to have another visit with Sharon at Frick last Friday, but she was at a conference. I will perhaps be able to see her one more time before the semester ends, which is disappointing, as I thought I would get a lot more visits in. Oh, well.

We were talking in class a couple of weeks ago about how blind people use the Web, and I was wondering how that works. One way that usability is improving is by describing images and then having a text reader give the description. It’s interesting we were talking about it, because I just read an article in a recent Smithsonianmagazine about a computer scientist named Luis von Ahn at Carnegie Mellon University who’s using “participatory Web” technologies to help label images for the disabled. It’s interesting work, though I was a bit dismayed by von Ahn’s utopianism. The article can be read at http://www.smithsonianmag.com/specialsections/innovators/von-ahn.html.

Well, I have to go catch a bus now. Hopefully I won’t go too crazy over break thinking about all the stuff I have to get done before the semester ends.

Fourth Visit

November 10, 2007

I had my fourth visit with Sharon at Frick last Friday (November 2). It was a really good meeting. She wanted to work on a PowerPoint presentation, which made me nervous initially, as Power Point is not one of my strong points. However, I need not have been worried, as Sharon found her way around PowerPoint pretty well, much better than I thought she would. I helped her out with some formatting and presentation issues, but she more or less did it herself, which was encouraging to see. I think PowerPoint may be among the most user-friendly Office programs, though, since it’s used so extensively. And it turns out that Microsoft still has the edge as far as presentation software capability. While it sounds like the Google office software is good at just about everything that MS Office is, it still hasn’t cracked PowerPoint: http://www.slate.com/id/2176549/

I also wonder if my initial trepidation wasn’t influenced by my cumulative experience so far. What I mean by this is that I’ve become so accustomed to assuming that things are going to be complex and difficult to explain to a newer user, but there are times when things are really simple, and maybe I’ve forgotten that. I think the Digital Citizenship class, with all its hard questions about technology, has complicated IT in my mind, too, which is probably affecting my service-learning outlook.

Today I was supposed to teach some of the other teachers at Frick the things I’ve taught Sharon. However, Sharon emailed me earlier in the week and called it off. I’m glad she did, but now I’m wondering how I’m going to fit my hours in. I’ve only got 8 so far, and I need 20, which is a lot when you start to think about it. I’m hoping to squeeze in the teacher symposium, because that will give me a ton (Sharon was thinking I’d be at the school from 9 am to 3 pm).  We’ll see.

P.S. The WordPress spell check doesn’t recognize “Google,” so maybe the company hasn’t conquered the entire Web yet.